In Tremendous Bowl XLVI 4 years later, Manning beat Invoice Belichick and Tom Brady once more 21-17.
So whenever you think about two rings along with his profession totals, and let’s face it, his final identify, Manning is destined to obtain sufficient votes sooner or later. Nevertheless, in case you dissect Manning’s profession, there is a case these Tremendous Bowls and his final identify aren’t sufficient to make him a first-ballot Corridor of Famer.
Throughout his 16-year profession, Manning passed for 57,023 yards and 366 touchdowns. However he additionally threw 244 interceptions, thirteenth most in NFL historical past, per StatMuse.
Manning, who by no means led the league in TD passes or some other optimistic passing class, led the NFL in interceptions 3 times. In 2007, the season he beat the Patriots in his first Tremendous Bowl, he led the NFL with 20 interceptions.
Manning additionally led the league in interceptions in 2010 (25) and 2013 (27). In reality, he reached double digits in interceptions in all however two of his 16 seasons — the 9 video games he performed as a rookie and the 4 of his ultimate NFL season in 2019.
An argument towards Manning is not simply concerning the turnovers. Brett Favre, the NFL’s all-time chief in interceptions with 366, was a first-ballot HOF choice and is commonly considered one of many top-10 biggest QBs.
However there’s an enormous distinction between Favre and Manning — “The Gunslinger” was a far more accomplished participant than Manning. He was an 11-time Professional Bowler, gained three MVPs and made first-team All-Professional 3 times.
In contrast, Manning made 4 Professional Bowls, by no means was named All-Professional and by no means sniffed MVP consideration. Sure, Manning has yet another Tremendous Bowl ring than Favre, however that is a workforce accomplishment above all else.
Manning will ultimately be enshrined within the Corridor of Fame. If we take a look at a sports activities Corridor of Fame as a museum to chronicle the historical past of the sport, Manning deserves a spot in Canton.
However solely 89 of the 371 present Professional Soccer Corridor of Famers earned induction of their first 12 months of eligibility. Incomes the Corridor of Fame on the primary poll is an honor that ought to be reserved for candidates who’re the creme de la creme of soccer gamers. Manning is not among the many better of the most effective.
Awarding the previous New York Giants nice — one of many extra polarizing HOF candidates in current reminiscence — with a variety on the primary poll could be flawed.
