Unlock the Editor’s Digest free of charge
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.
German direct funding into China has risen sharply this yr, in an indication that firms in Europe’s largest financial system are ignoring pleas from their authorities to diversify into different, much less geopolitically dangerous markets.
Figures supplied to the Monetary Occasions by the Bundesbank, Germany’s central financial institution, present that German direct investments in China stood at €2.48bn within the first three months of 2024, rising to €4.8bn within the second quarter.
That brings the overall for the primary half of 2024 to €7.3bn, in contrast with €6.5bn for the entire of 2023.
The funding, a lot of it pushed by huge German carmakers, comes regardless of warnings from Olaf Scholz’s authorities in regards to the rising geopolitical dangers related to the Chinese language market.
Ursula von der Leyen, European Fee president, has called on companies throughout the EU to “de-risk” from Asia’s largest financial system.
Many in Europe fear that Germany’s enterprise leaders haven’t learnt the teachings of the Ukraine warfare, which uncovered its harmful entanglement with Russia and its over-reliance on Russian gasoline.
The worry is that an escalation of geopolitical tensions within the Taiwan Strait might show disastrous for the numerous German firms with in depth — and deepening — ties to China.
It might additionally reduce Germany off from lots of the essential inputs and uncooked supplies wanted within the manufacturing of every thing from chemical compounds to photo voltaic cells and batteries for electrical automobiles. Germany’s reliance on Chinese language imports is especially excessive within the case of uncommon earth metals reminiscent of scandium and yttrium.
Specialists say a lot of the funding {dollars} are reinvested earnings earned in China. Analysis by the Cologne Institute for Financial Analysis (IW Köln) has proven that greater than half of the €19bn in earnings made by German firms in China final yr was reinvested there.
They stated the uptick in German direct funding mirrored a brand new “In China, for China” technique pursued by firms like Volkswagen geared toward shifting extra manufacturing to considered one of their largest markets.
“Corporations noticed lots of bottlenecks forming throughout the pandemic and the blockade of the Suez Canal,” stated Friedolin Strack, a China knowledgeable on the BDI, Germany’s important enterprise foyer. “They’re decided to cut back all dangers of their provide chains by reorganising them on a regional foundation, via localisation. That’s taking place rather a lot in China, particularly.”
However Jürgen Matthes, an knowledgeable on German-China commerce at IW Köln, warned the technique would find yourself harming the German home financial system.
“It’s a safeguard in opposition to doable geopolitical dangers, like an escalation within the Taiwan Strait, nevertheless it’s to the detriment of the German financial system and the German labour market,” he stated. “We will probably be exporting much less to China, and extra will probably be manufactured in China by Chinese language employees.”
The newest figures come simply over a yr after Scholz’s authorities adopted Germany’s first ever China technique, a plan that was predicated on the necessity for Europe’s largest financial system to “de-risk” its relations with China.
Whereas insisting he opposed the concept of “decoupling” Germany from China, and utterly severing ties, Scholz warned firms “to not put all their eggs in a single basket”. The technique referred to as on German firms to diversify their provide chains and export markets away from China and so cut back the nation’s vulnerability to exterior shocks.
However there has to date been little proof that firms — particularly the massive carmakers — are heeding the federal government’s admonitions.
Danielle Goh, an analyst at US-based analysis group Rhodium Group, stated the “robust momentum’ of German funding in China would proceed via the remainder of the yr.
She cited a variety of big-ticket bulletins in latest months, reminiscent of Volkswagen’s plan to take a position €2.5bn in increasing its manufacturing and innovation hub within the metropolis of Hefei, in Anhui province, and BMW’s deliberate €2.5bn in its Shenyang Manufacturing Base.
“Over the previous 5 years, German investments have persistently accounted for greater than 50 per cent of EU27 investments in China, predominantly because of contributions from German carmakers,” she stated.
Some enterprise leaders privately categorical concern in regards to the German automotive business’s deepening involvement in China. Volkswagen specifically has come underneath large criticism over its operations in Xinjiang, the place the Chinese language authorities stand accused of widescale repression of the Uyghur inhabitants.
“A few of them are simply too reliant on the earnings they make in China,” stated one. “They’re caught in a form of golden cage.”
